top of page
435 W Duke of Gloucester Street
Williamsburg's original cupcakery. In business for 14 years and counting. For 10 years, we were located at 1220 Richmond Road. 4 years ago we moved into Illy Caffe in Merchant's Square.
Different location, same extraordinary cupcakes.
Monday - Saturday
Monday - Saturday Remarkable Red Velvet
Classic red cake with cream cheese icing
4.95
$4.95
Uncommon Carrot
Moist cake with fresh grated carrots, crushed pineapple, walnuts and Vietnamese cinnamon and a cream cheese icing.
4.95
$4.95
Marvelous Madagascar
Our best seller! We make this traditional pound cake with Madagascar Vanilla, from the island of Madagascar.
Yes, it is a pound cake so it is a dense vanilla bean cake with Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing.
5.45
$5.45
Wicked Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake topped with rich chocolate icing.
4.95
$4.95
Fantastic Chocolate Flip
Our Wicked chocolate cake – with Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing.
4.95
$4.95
Fantastic Vanilla Flip
Our Marvelous Vanilla cake – with rich Wicked chocolate icing
4.95
$4.95
Phenomenal Peanut Butter
Wicked Chocolate cake, creamy peanut butter filling, peanut butter buttercream icing.
5.45
$5.45
Gluten Free Cupcakes
We are excited to use Chef Thomas Keller’s Gluten Free C4C Flour. We offer 2 flavors of gluten free cake - vanilla and chocolate. We customize your cupcakes with your choice of icing and filling.
5.95 unfilled 6.45 filled
$6.45
Gluten free
Now available daily - Luscious Lemon Raspberry
A moist lemon cake filled with rich Raspberry compound and topped with a Raspberry buttercream icing.
5.45
$5.45
ALL AUTUMN LONG - Sensational S'Mores
Chocolate cake, marshmallow, graham cracker and chocolate filling covered in milk chocolate and topped off with an Extraordinary sized toasted marshmallow!
$5
September - Awesome Almond Blackberry
Moist almond cake is filled with sweet blackberry puree, then it's topped with a Blackberry Buttercream & white chocolate!
$5.45
Strawberry Shortcake Push Pop
Layers of Madagascar icing, fresh cut strawberries, and vanilla cake. Delicious! Ready and waiting for you in the grab and go fridge inside Illy Caffe Williamsburg.
$5.45
Our Monthly & Seasonal Specials!
ALL WINTER LONG - Gregarious German Chocolate
Super-light chocolate cake with a pecan & coconut caramel frosting and a rich coconut & pecan filling.
$5
January - Miraculous Mint Cocoa
Rich chocolate cake is filled with a fluffy mint cream and topped with a Vanilla/Mint Buttercream!
$5
February - Ravishing Chocolate Raspberry
Wicked Chocolate Cake filled with raspberry puree and iced with a raspberry buttercream frosting.
$5
March - Brilliant Bananas Foster
It just needs the ice cream! Rich banana cupcake with banana filling and a decadent caramel frosting.
$5
May - Incredible Cookies and Cream
marble swirled vanilla and chocolate cake with a decadent cookies and creme filling, topped with vanilla buttercream icing and crushed cookies.
$5
August - Illustrious Key Lime
A lime zest cake with key lime pastry cream filling topped with a fluffy icing & fresh lime zest!
$5
September - Awesome Almond Blackberry
Moist almond cake is filled with sweet blackberry puree, then it's topped with a Blackberry Buttercream & white chocolate!
$5.45
October - Amazing Apple Brown Betty
Moist spiced cake with baked apples, a soft vanilla frosting and a local Apple Butter Crumble!
$5
November - The Great Pumpkin
Vanilla cake with a dash of cinnamon, pumpkin pie filling and light cinnamon cream cheese frosting.
$5
December - Wondrous Gingerbread
gingerbread cake, topped with sweet cinnamon buttercream icing, adorned with a classic gingerbread man!
$4.50
April - Tremendous Tres Leches
An inspired creation that highlights soft vanilla and cream! A super moist 3 milk (drenched!) cake with a fluffy frosting. (Our thanks to Manny's mom at Kuba Kuba in Richmond for her inspirational cake!)
$5.45
Bewitching Blueberry Lemon
Soft Vanilla cake with local blueberries baked inside, a rich lemon custard filling and a Blueberry Cream Cheese icing - super delicious!
$5.45
July - Impeccable Peaches & Cream
A peach vanilla cake filled with peach and mascarpone, topped with a peach buttercream icing and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
5.45
$5.45
June 21 - September 20 Stupendous Strawberry Shortcake
We puree locally grown, organic strawberries to fill this light vanilla cake, and top it off with a strawberry buttercream icing. Summer never tasted so good!
5.45
$5.45
Not Cupcakes
We don't just make cupcakes and cakes! We also make cheesecake, tiramisu, caramel apple bread pudding, mini cannoli, and many more. Call us to discuss the possibilities!.OMG NY Cheesecake
Super-Rich, extra tall Carnegie Deli style Cheesecake - because who does it better than Carnegie Deli? Each cheesecake takes hours and hours to make, but you get to enjoy it with no waiting!
$5
Whoopie Pies
It's tender Red Velvet cake with Cream Cheese filling stuffed inside - need we say more?
$5
Walnut Mousse Bars
Savory crushed walnuts on the bottom, smooth chocolate ganache and a layer of fluffy chocolate mousse to top it off!
$5
Gluten free
Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding
Sylvia gets all the credit for this one - but I can't imagine my childhood without it! Creamy pudding, vanilla wafers,
sliced bananas - pure goodness! (Monday, Tuesday & Wednesday only!)
$6
bottom of page